This is the
first in a new series of periodic updates that CMEP has initiated to
highlight key issues, analyses and resources on the Arab-Israeli
conflict.
===================================================================================
-
Issue Highlight: After the Gaza
Withdrawal, What Next?
-
Where to on the
Road Map Peace Plan?
-
Jerusalem News
-
Update on
Christians in the Holy Land
===================================================================================
1. Issue Highlight: After the Gaza
Withdrawal, What Next?
The world watched
with appreciation and relief as Israel completed its historic
withdrawal from Gaza and four settlements in the West Bank in less
time than most had anticipated and with almost no violence
(demolition of settler’s homes and evacuation of military
installations continue and should be completed by mid-September).
Now many are turning their attention to the road ahead. What’s next
after the Gaza withdrawal and how can both parties maintain this
momentum to make progress on the Road Map peace plan? The articles
listed below provide helpful guidance on how the United States can
encourage further positive steps forward by Israel and the
Palestinians.
“The Road After
Gaza”:
Robert Malley and Aaron D. Miller,
Washington Post,
August 24, 2005
“…Israel wants
time to digest a traumatic disengagement. Palestinians need
convincing that it is only a first step. A feasible middle course
would entail focusing on rapid, practical improvements in the West
Bank, such as Israeli withdrawal from reoccupied cities, a lifting
of checkpoints and release of prisoners, in tandem with improved
Palestinian security performance. It would also entail preventing
steps that prejudge final-status issues and might in fact preclude
their resolution…”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/08/23/AR2005082301177.html
“How Sharon and Abbas Can Both Win”:
Khalil Shikaki,
Jerusalem Post,
August 16, 2005.
“…successful coordination might not only facilitate the dismantling
of the infrastructure of violence, but as importantly, a return to
meaningful negotiations. Moreover, for the Palestinian president,
Mahmoud Abbas and the Israeli prime minister, Ariel Sharon,
successful coordination promises stronger hands in defeating their
domestic foes by delivering economic prosperity and improved
security.”
http://www.commongroundnews.org/index.php?mode=1&lang=en&PHPSESSID=f3b74aa1125f6a3cabf04e31c4a36474#939
“Gaza withdrawal: winners and losers”:
Four
Israeli and Palestinian Viewpoints, Bitterlemons.org, Aug.
29, 2005
(Bitterlemons is a
website that presents Israeli and Palestinian viewpoints on
prominent issues of concern. It focuses on the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict and peace process.)
http://www.bitterlemons.org/previous/bl290805ed31.html
2.
Where to on the
Road Map Peace Plan?
Road Map
Sponsors to Meet on September 20th:
In August, the
sponsors of the Road Map—The United Nations, the United States, the
European Union and Russia---announced that they will meet in
mid-September to assess Israel’s disengagement from Gaza and the
northern West Bank. At the last meeting of the Quartet on June 23,
members issued support for Israel’s pullout – calling it “a moment
of optimism, an opportunity that should not be missed” – and
reaffirmed that the “the two-state vision and the road map are the
best way to achieve a permanent peace and an end to [Israel’s]
occupation” of the West Bank and Gaza.”
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/612935.html
“Rev up the
road map”,
Dennis Ross, The Jerusalem Post, August 30, 2005
”…the administration must build a bridge to the future. The two
sides have very different expectations of what will happen after
disengagement: Sharon wants a pause to absorb the emotional trauma,
and Abbas wants next steps. Each needs an explanation of what is
next. The administration should declare that it will take the
moribund road map and negotiate a common understanding on every
Israeli and Palestinian obligation.”
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull&cid=1125368484250&p=1006953079865
3. Jerusalem News
Settlement
expansion in the Jerusalem area:
Over the summer a number of plans were announced by the Israeli
government regarding settlement expansion in the Jerusalem area,
including the seizure of West Bank land to extend the separation
barrier around the settlement of Maale Adumim, preparations to build
a new police station east of Jerusalem in what is known as the E-1
area and initial plans to build a new Jewish settlement in the heart
of the Muslim Quarter of the Old City. These developments could
threaten the peace of the city at this fragile time.
Resources:
Ir Amim,
("City of
Nations", "City of peoples") is an Israeli organization that was
founded in order to actively engage in those issues impacting
Israeli-Palestinian relations in Jerusalem and the political future
of the city. Ir Amim’s key professionals released a position paper
in August discussing new settlement expansion in Jerusalem and how
it damages long-term Israeli interests.
http://www.ir-amim.org.il/EngArticles/JerusalemInTheShadow.html
Americans for
Peace Now
released a new Settlements in Focus report, “Targeting the Old
City’s Muslim Quarter”, on August 19, 2005, providing details and
background on Israel’s plans to build a Jewish settlement in the Old
City (produced by Lara Friedman,
Government Relations Director at Americans for Peace Now and Daniel
Seidemann, founder and Consulting Legal Advisor for Ir Amim).
http://www.peacenow.org/briefs.asp?rid=&cid=1316
4. Update on
Christians in the Holy Land
Christian Presence in the Holy Land Diminishing
The
Standing Conference of Orthodox Bishops in America issued a
statement of alarm concerning the diminishing presence of Christians
in the Middle East (the majority of Palestinian Christians are of
the Greek Orthodox Christian tradition). Below is an excerpt from
their statement:
“…As
a consequence of the violent confrontations and the poverty and
economic instability of the Palestinian population, emigration from
the region continues and accelerates. Thus, the entire Christian
population, and especially the Orthodox Christian population, is
diminished month by month. In demographic terms, within the
foreseeable future the Holy Land will be a land of holy sites and
holy stones, with the Christian population reduced to the status of
mere custodians of these holy places, no longer able to maintain a
viable community life….”
http://www.scoba.us/news/newsdetail.asp?id=145
Holy Land
Lutheran Bishop Calls for Reconciliation Between Palestinians and
Israelis
Bishop Dr. Munib
A. Younan of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy
Land (ELCJHL) delivered the opening sermon of the Lutheran World
Federation Council Meeting held in
Jerusalem from
August 31- September 6. Younan affirmed that a two-state solution
with a shared Jerusalem is possible if Israelis and Palestinians
realize their interdependence. His sermon emphasized that for
true reconciliation to take place people must be willing to hear the
truth about each other and to forgive:
“…At
the core of any reconciliation is the readiness of people in the
conflict to anticipate a shared future together…I urge all Israelis
to see God in the Palestinians and urge all Palestinians to see God
in the Israelis. I urge both to accept each other's humanity with
all of its pain and suffering. If we do so in the spirit of
forgiveness, then we can recognize each others human, civil,
religious, national and political rights. Only then will the Holy
Land be the Promised Land of milk and honey for Palestinians and
Israelis. It is my fervent prayer that my children and grandchildren
will live one day side by side with their Israeli neighbors in just
peace and reconciliation.”
http://www.lutheranworld.org/council/2005/20050830-council.html
===================================================================================
The views
expressed by the authors of the articles included do not necessarily
reflect those of Churches for Middle East Peace (CMEP). CMEP is a
coalition of 21 Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant church bodies and
organizations that work together in pursuit of a peaceful resolution
of the Arab-Israeli conflict where two viable states, Israel and
Palestine, live side-by-side within secure and recognized borders.
For more
information contact Julie Schumacher Cohen, CMEP’s Legislative
Assistant at 202-543-1222 or at
Julie@cmep.org.