The murder of American values in Lebanon
By Ann Zwicker Kerr
Christian Science Monitor
August 14, 2006
Ann Zwicker Kerr was a student at the American
University of Beirut in the 1950s and has recently
interviewed six of her former classmates. Her late husband
Malcolm Kerr was president of AUB from 1982-84 and was
assassinated in office.
LOS ANGELES – "America is murdering the values it
taught us," my former fellow classmate from the American
University of Beirut (AUB) cried out when I visited her in
Amman this spring.
Salma's words echoed the pain my family and I had been
living with for 22 years, since two unidentified gunmen
assassinated my husband on the campus of the American
University of Beirut - pain that is reinforced with each
day of bombing in Lebanon and Israel and underscored by
the many recent deaths in Qana and elsewhere, as well as
the insubstantial cease-fire.
“Oh, how I miss Malcolm," Salma said to me, referring to
my husband. She was implying that he was an American in a
position of influence whom she could trust and who could
interpret the Muslim world to the West. "Islam is so
distorted and misunderstood - it makes me feel more Muslim
than I ever felt before. I feel cornered - drawn inward,
mistrusted, and plotted against. American politics is
anti-Arab." This came from a woman, now in her 70s, whose
early goals in life had been fulfilled when she graduated
from AUB and eventually earned her PhD at the University
of California at Los Angeles.
Those who shot Malcolm killed not just a man but a set of
values he embodied as the president of the American
University of Beirut, an institution that had brought
ideals of open inquiry and tolerance to the Middle East
for more than a hundred years - and had in turn been
enriched by the students and professors from the entire
region who came to learn and teach there. But American
policy in the region was increasingly contradicting
American values symbolized by AUB.
Like me, my classmates know how values can fall victim to
mindless acts of violence. Soon after the assassination,
an anony-mous caller to Agence France Presse claimed
responsibility in the name of Islamic Jihad. "How could an
Arab have killed Malcolm?" my friends murmured at
Malcolm's memorial service on the university campus in
1984. "He was a scholar of the Middle East who was born
here and loved this country." In those chaotic days of the
Lebanese civil war, we had only just begun to hear the
name Hizbullah.
This Shiite Islamist movement had spilled over into
Lebanon from the Iranian revolution and filled the vacuum
left by the forced departure of Yasser Arafat and his
Palestinian Liberation Organization. In the absence of a
strong central government, Hizbullah joined sectarian
rivals vying for power in a country that was weak-ened by
the meddling of its neighbors, Syria and Israel. Hizbullah
claimed the role of defender of Lebanon and the
Palestinians against Israel and the United States, while
at the same time winning credit among the poor by
providing much needed social services and education.
The tragic cross-border fighting of the past few weeks,
with both sides unrestrained by the US, has escalated into
a war that might engulf the entire region as well as what
is left of faith in American ideals in the Muslim world.
"The United States should not be the most powerful nation
in the world and the least just," another of my
classmates, Naziha, told me in Beirut. "We believed so
much in the American values we learned at AUB, and now
those are being betrayed."
A Shiite Muslim whose father studied at AUB before her,
she understands the tension between the beacon of
enlightenment that is America and the tunnel vision that
all too often defines our foreign policy. Naziha's two
children studied at the university and later earned PhDs
in the US, and her daughter returned to teach at AUB. How
can this family and others keep their faith in the ideals
they have long associated with America when they hear that
the US government rushed an order of precision bombs to
Israel, which are now being dropped on their city?
Salma and Naziha's present hopes for a bilateral,
negotiated two-state solution of the Palestinian- Israeli
problem, and their faith that the US could help bring this
about, are being smashed with every bomb that falls in
Lebanon, Israel, and Gaza. When will we have the courage
to stop fighting violence with violence and use our
position of power and wealth to promote peace through
diplomacy, not militancy?
The bond of 50 years of friendship with my friends from
AUB helps me remember Malcolm's true legacy: to cling to
those values of American enlightenment that have connected
us for so long. Narrow sectarian thinking and rampant
violence from whatever quarter can, in the long run, only
be corrected by a higher and nobler vision.